Skip to main content

TrustTracker / A question of trust

Issue 1 · Published

What can an average hide?

A single BBC trust score conceals quite different views among people with different political identities.

An average can make trust look like a single verdict. But in our England surveys, respondents who voted Conservative in 2019 gave the BBC an average trust score of 3.17 out of 7. Among Labour voters the average was 3.88; among Liberal Democrat voters, 4.54.

Trust in the BBC differs by political identity.

Average BBC trust among respondents in England who reported voting for these three parties in the 2019 general election.

https://doi.org/10.7910/DVN/AUE81C | December 2022–June 2024. Descriptive, unweighted means calculated from the published replication data. Conservative n=3,999; Labour n=2,886; Liberal Democrat n=1,058. Other parties and unknown votes are omitted. Trust runs from 1 (lowest) to 7 (highest). This chart covers England; the paper separately compares the BBC with NHK in Japan. image/svg+xml Matplotlib v3.10.8, https://matplotlib.org/ 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Mean trust, 1–7 Conservative Labour Liberal Democrat 3.17 3.88 4.54 TrustTracker calculations from Pickering, Sunahara & Hansen (2025), replication data

December 2022–June 2024. Descriptive, unweighted means calculated from the published replication data. Conservative n=3,999; Labour n=2,886; Liberal Democrat n=1,058. Other parties and unknown votes are omitted. Trust runs from 1 (lowest) to 7 (highest). This chart covers England; the paper separately compares the BBC with NHK in Japan.

TrustTracker calculations from Pickering, Sunahara & Hansen (2025), replication data →

Read the chart values
BBC trust, seven-point scale
2019 voteMean BBC trustObservations
Conservative3.173999
Labour3.882886
Liberal Democrat4.541058

These are descriptive differences, not evidence that a party vote causes trust or distrust. They show why asking whether the public trusts a broadcaster is only a starting point. Asking which audiences trust it can reveal a different story.

The wider study compares the BBC with Japan’s NHK. It finds different patterns of political alignment around the two broadcasters. That comparison raises a practical question: how can public-service news serve a shared audience when expectations of it differ?

The next question.

What do people mean when they ask a broadcaster to be impartial? Our ongoing studies examine those expectations and how they relate to support for public-service funding.

Inside the impartiality study →

Follow the evidence.

Research support

The original TrustTracker research programme was supported by the Japan Society for the Promotion of Science (JSPS, grant reference JPJSJRP 20211704) and the UK Research and Innovation's Economic and Social Research Council (UKRI-ESRC, grant reference ES/W011913/1).

JSPS and UKRI/ ESRC logos