Skip to main content

TrustTracker / Media & impact

← All media & impact

Commentary · Article

What the BBC Lacks: The Crucial Difference Between Britain’s Troubled Broadcaster and Japan’s NHK

Newsweek Japan · 18 November 2025

Steve Pickering examines the BBC’s crisis of legitimacy through a comparison with Japan’s NHK.

Read the article at Newsweek Japan →

In this commentary for Newsweek Japan, Steve Pickering contrasts the BBC’s current crisis of legitimacy with the enduring public trust enjoyed by Japan’s NHK, following controversy over the editing of a Trump speech.

Drawing directly on TrustTracker survey data from the UK and Japan, the piece shows how trust in the BBC has become sharply polarised along political lines, while attitudes toward NHK remain comparatively stable across the ideological spectrum. The article situates the BBC’s troubles not simply as a question of editorial error, but as a deeper structural challenge facing public service broadcasting in polarised democracies.

Research support

The original TrustTracker research programme was supported by the Japan Society for the Promotion of Science (JSPS, grant reference JPJSJRP 20211704) and the UK Research and Innovation's Economic and Social Research Council (UKRI-ESRC, grant reference ES/W011913/1).

JSPS and UKRI/ ESRC logos